At 81 years old, Paul Simon remains an influential figure in the music industry, boasting a career spanning over six decades. Beginning alongside Art Garfunkel, the duo explored a multitude of musical genres, including ventures into world music. In his later years, Simon released a distinctive album titled “Seven Psalms,” a nearly forty-minute-long single track that showcases his soothing vocals and guitar prowess, delivering profound themes.
Recognizing the extensive scope of Simon’s career, Alex Gibney crafted a comprehensive two-part documentary, “In Restless Dreams: The Music of Paul Simon,” spanning over three hours. This cinematic journey offers avid fans an in-depth exploration of Simon’s enduring impact on popular culture, reminiscent of his famed “Eras Tour.”
The focal point of “In Restless Dreams” is Simon’s recording sessions for “Seven Psalms” in 2021 at his Texas studio. Throughout the film, Simon provides introspective reflections on pivotal moments in his career. Directed by Alex Gibney, known for his adept handling of politically charged subjects, the documentary seamlessly integrates interviews, narration, and archival footage to delve into Simon’s largely controversy-free trajectory.
While acknowledging the challenges Simon encountered in his career, the documentary only lightly brushes upon them. The first episode, humorously titled “Verse One,” delves into his early collaborations with Garfunkel and their subsequent falling out. Simon’s solo career setbacks, including the commercial underperformance of “One Trick Pony” and criticism for cultural appropriation on “Graceland,” are also touched upon briefly.
Simon’s relentless pursuit of musical perfection is a recurring theme throughout the documentary. From the impromptu creation of “Mrs. Robinson” to the meticulous crafting of “Seven Psalms,” his unwavering dedication to his craft is palpable. Whether collaborating with Garfunkel or immersing himself in jam sessions with South African musicians, Simon’s commitment to excellence shines through.
The documentary, however, misses opportunities to delve deeper into significant aspects of Simon’s life, such as his feud with Garfunkel and accusations of cultural appropriation. Contemporary footage feels somewhat disjointed from archival material, as Simon’s focus in 2021 is primarily on completing “Seven Psalms.”
Presented as a shy yet amiable figure, Simon reflects on his life alongside his wife and younger collaborators. While the film caters to die-hard fans by glossing over controversies and personal relationships, it primarily celebrates Simon’s musical achievements, akin to a greatest hits compilation.
Despite its length, “In Restless Dreams” leaves viewers craving more, especially concerning Simon’s later career. However, Gibney’s decision to prioritize showcasing Simon’s musical prowess over a critical examination of the artist is understandable given Simon’s enduring appeal.
Simon’s vulnerability, as seen in his admission of fear during recording sessions, juxtaposed with his vibrant stage presence, paints a multifaceted portrait of the legendary musician. “In Restless Dreams” serves as a reverent tribute to Paul Simon, capturing both the highs and lows of his remarkable career.
| Aspect | Coverage |
|---|---|
| Early Career | Explores collaborations with Art Garfunkel, including their falling out, and Simon’s solo career setbacks. |
| Musical Achievements | Highlights Simon’s musical achievements, including hits like “Hey Schoolgirl” and reunion concerts. |
| Perfectionism | Demonstrates Simon’s dedication to his craft, from spontaneous creation to meticulous attention to detail. |
| Controversies | Briefly touches on controversies like cultural appropriation but does not delve deeply into them. |
| Personal Life | Skirts around personal aspects, focusing more on musical successes and Simon’s reflections on his career. |
| Relationship with Garfunkel | Brief mentions and archival footage, missed opportunity for a deeper exploration or reunion between the two. |
| Direction and Production | Directed by Alex Gibney, primarily focuses on Simon’s recording sessions for Seven Psalms and his reflections. |
| Audience | Curated for die-hard fans, offers highlights of Simon’s career but glosses over controversies and personal life. |
| Tone | Portrays Simon as a shy yet friendly figure, showcasing both vulnerable and vibrant moments in his life. |
